Selective

“More Than Theater: Celebrating the 250th Anniversary of the Bolshoi Theatre”
Museum of Contemporary Russian History
Moscow, Russia
November 01, 2026

by Ilona Landgraf
Copyright © 2026 by Ilona Landgraf

1. Maria Suvorova, “The Greatest Theater” © MustART GalleryThe announcement of a large-scale exhibition to celebrate the Bolshoi Theatre’s 250th birthday made me reflect on the period from 1776 (when Empress Catherine the Great granted Prince Pyotr Urusov permission to establish a theater company in Moscow, the Bolshoi Theatre’s predecessor) to today, admittedly, a gigantic undertaking. But, after all, the Bolshoi is Russia’s most prestigious theater.

But the Museum of Contemporary Russian History’s exhibition More Than Theater takes a different approach. In collaboration with Moscow’s private MustART Gallery, the museum assigned sixteen contemporary Russian artists to “unravel the Bolshoi’s stage’s captivating and infinite mystery.” It is questionable whether the paintings, drawings, sculptures, and installations to which the theater added archived video performances achieved this goal. Many of the works show past and present artists, but the selection criteria remained unclear. I didn’t count the objects but had the impression that the ballet company was better represented than the opera company.

3. Exhibition “More Than Theater: Celebrating the 250th Anniversary of the Bolshoi Theatre” © MustART Gallery2. Viktor Korneev, bust of Valery Gergiev © MustART Gallery Maria Suvorova’s painting of The Bolshoi Theatre’s Apollo Quadriga at the pediment greets visitors as if they are approaching the real Bolshoi. A painting of the historic auditorium (also by Suvorova) flanks Apollo and his horses on the right and the Bolshoi’s key figures on the left. A bronze bust of general director Valery Gergiev (cast by Viktor Korneev) stands in front of a line of paintings of Ivan Vsevolozhsky (the director of Moscow’s Imperial Theaters from 1881-1886), Yuri Grigorovich (the Bolshoi Ballet’s defining choreographer and, until 1995, artistic director), and Makhar Vaziev (the Bolshoi Ballet’s current artistic director). Opposite them, a model of the Bolshoi Theater’s proscenium with a ceremonial curtain pays tribute to the Russian-Italian architect, Albert Cavos (1801-1863), who designed the Bolshoi’s reconstruction and extension after the devastating1853 fire.

4. Oleg Zakomorny, “Anticipation of Dance” © MustART Gallery5. Vladimir Shtein, “Nina Kaptsova and Darina Moseyeva” © MustART Gallery 6. Maksim Aksenov, bust of Yaroslava Kuprina © MustART GalleryIn the second room, two objects immediately attract the eye: the large bust Anticipation of Dance of the Bolshoi Ballet’s prima ballerina, Svetlana Zakharova, and Nina Kaptsova’s smile and pose in a huge painting by Vladimir Cherny showing her rehearsing Darina Moseyeva. Only on a second glance did I notice the portrait of Pyotr Tchaikovsky (wearing a brown jacket with gray trimmings, he looks strangely out of date) and the huge painting of Yuri Grigorovich draped in a chair next to the stage curtain.

8. Vladimir Cherny, “Pyotr Ilyich Tchaikovsky” © MustART Gallery7. Dmitry Slepushkin, “Portrait of Choreographer Yuri Grigorovich” © MustART GalleryAmong the smaller sculptures arranged behind Zakharova’s bust is one of Yaroslavna Kuprina, a bronze of Alyona Kovalyova as Aegina from Spartacus, and another sculpture of Zakharova performing a développé à la seconde. To capture the individuality of the Bolshoi’s artists, the painters and sculptors worked alongside them for a year.

Given the sideways glance of Artemy Belyakov’s Solor at colleagues from a subtle portrait (by Andrei Remnev), he must prefer restraint. On paintings next to him, Igor Stravinsky tinkles the ivories, and Tamara Karsavina sports a colorful Firebird costume.

9. Andrei Remnev, “Solor. Artemy Belyakov” © MustART Gallery10. Oleg Zakomorny, “A Ray of Light: Svetlana Zakharova” © MustART Gallery11. Oleg Osnach, “Dress Rehearsal” © MustART GalleryThe letters of Les Saisons Russes on a blue theater curtain of a Bakst-like painting are built from rose-colored harem dancers. Enlarged tickets to the Bolshoi are displayed on the opposite wall, one dated 1916/17, seven years after the Ballets Russes’ sensational debut in Paris—a subscription ticket for ten performances costing forty rubles. By the standard of the time, going to the theater was expensive.

12. Viktor Korneev, “Igor Stravinsky” © MustART Gallery The center of the exhibition is a small round room that, due to the curtains at its entrance and exit, feels like a private box. Only one visitor sits in it (on a plain wooden chair rather than a red cushioned seat from the auditorium that spans behind him): a wood-carved Igor Stravinsky. His upper body leans forward as if the seat were hot. His hands hover tensely above his knees as if ready to intervene in the performance of his Firebird, which unravels on screen in front of him.

 

 

 

13. Maria Kulagina, “Music of Time: The Conductor” © MustART GalleryMaria Kulagina’s orchestra installation dominates the following room. Its bulky cellists bend over instruments made of wooden planks, the violinists poke their bows in the air like lances, and the conductor hangs angel-like above them, his body supported by a music stand. Maybe he’s conducting Dmitry Shostakovich’s Lady Macbeth of Mtsensk, an excerpt of which plays on the side wall. Maria Suvorova depicted Shostakovich twice: as a young man playing piano and as a mature artist. Of the two dance shoes in Olga Osnach’s painting, the braided bast shoe represents the connection to the ground, whereas the pointe shoe symbolizes aspiration toward heaven.

 

15. Exhibition “More Than Theater: Celebrating the 250th Anniversary of the Bolshoi Theatre” © MustART Gallery14. Svetlana Valuyeva, The Opera “Semyon Kotko” © MustART GallerySergei Prokofiev would have celebrated his 135th birthday this year. The Bolshoi’s schedule paid tribute to him last season, and this tribute extended to the exhibition, for which one room is reserved solely for Prokofiev. A video excerpt and the score of his opera Semyon Kotko are on display as well as sketches of the Bolshoi’s artists in Ivan the Terrible, Cinderella, Romeo and Juliet, and War and Peace.

The best vibes are in the final room, which features current leading artists. Sergei Bazilev’s strong color palette gives Svetlana Zakharova and Maria Vinogradova an intense presence, and Mikhail Novokshchenny’s broad brushstrokes catch Anastasia Stashkevich, Vyacheslav Lopatin, and Igor Tsvirko in rehearsals.
16. Sculpture of Maya Plisetskaya, Exhibition “More Than Theater: Celebrating the 250th Anniversary of the Bolshoi Theatre” © MustART Gallery 17. Vadim Kirillov, “Denis Rodkin and Eleonora Sevenard” © MustART GalleryDrawings on the opposite wall portray Valery Gergiev, Boris Akimov, Alexander Vetrov, Ekaterina Krysanova, and, again, Svetlana Zakharova. Vadim Kirillov’s bronze depicts Eleonora Sevenard and Denis Rodkin as Kitri and Basilio. Behind them, Rodkin and Zakharova dance Carmen Suite. Carmen was Maya Plisetskaya’s signature role. Although she and Yuri Grigorovich are no longer physically present in the Bolshoi, they feel eternally present, and perhaps that’s why portraits of both hang in the last room as well.

More than Theater runs until January 10, 2027.
18. Exhibition “More Than Theater: Celebrating the 250th Anniversary of the Bolshoi Theatre” © MustART Gallery

Links: Website of the Bolshoi Theatre
Website of the MustART Gallery
Website of the Museum of Contemporary Russian History
More Than Theater: Celebrating the 250th Anniversary of the Bolshoi Theatre—video
Photos: 1. Maria Suvorova, “The Greatest Theater”
2. Viktor Korneev, bust of Valery Gergiev
3. Exhibition “More Than Theater: Celebrating the 250th Anniversary of the Bolshoi Theatre”
4. Oleg Zakomorny, “Anticipation of Dance”
5. Vladimir Shtein, “Nina Kaptsova and Darina Moseyeva”
6. Maksim Aksenov, bust of Yaroslava Kuprina
7. Dmitry Slepushkin, “Portrait of Choreographer Yuri Grigorovich”
8. Vladimir Cherny, “Pyotr Ilyich Tchaikovsky”
9. Andrei Remnev, “Solor. Artemy Belyakov”
10. Oleg Zakomorny, “A Ray of Light: Svetlana Zakharova”
11. Oleg Osnach, “Dress Rehearsal”
12. Viktor Korneev, “Igor Stravinsky”
13. Maria Kulagina, “Music of Time: The Conductor”
14. Svetlana Valuyeva, The Opera “Semyon Kotko”
15. Exhibition “More Than Theater: Celebrating the 250th Anniversary of the Bolshoi Theatre”
16. Sculpture of Maya Plisetskaya, Exhibition “More Than Theater: Celebrating the 250th Anniversary of the Bolshoi Theatre”
17. Vadim Kirillov, “Denis Rodkin and Eleonora Sevenard”
18. Exhibition “More Than Theater: Celebrating the 250th Anniversary of the Bolshoi Theatre”
all photos © MustART Gallery
Editing: Kayla Kauffman

 

It Is What It Is

“Nijinsky”
Vienna State Ballet
Vienna State Opera
Vienna, Austria
October 20, 2026 (live stream)

by Ilona Landgraf
Copyright © 2026 by Ilona Landgraf

1. A.Frola (Vaslav Nijinsky) and ensemble, “Nijinsky” by J.Neumeier, Vienna State Ballet 2026 © Vienna State Ballet/A.Taylor The insight I gained from the Vienna State Ballet’s premiere of Nijinsky hit me at the curtain call when choreographer John Neumeier took his bow. He looks back on an oeuvre of more than 180 pieces, and though his foundation’s website announces a new choreography for 2027, his career is nearing its end. He held on past his prime and missed the right time to hand over his company. On stage, another career was over: Nijinsky’s. But he certainly hadn’t yet realized his full potential. Continue reading “It Is What It Is”

Resilient

“Masurca Fogo”
Tanztheater Wuppertal
Opera House
Wuppertal, Germany
October 02, 2026

by Ilona Landgraf
Copyright © 2026 by Ilona Landgraf

1. Ensemble, “Masurca Fogo” by P.Bausch, Tanztheater Wuppertal 2026 © A.BarbariniThe last time I saw the Tanztheater Wuppertal on their home stage was in 2014, five years after Pina Bausch’s untimely death. Gloom weighed on the Opera House. Its artistic heart had stopped beating, and tight finances worsened the outlook.

Longstanding members kept the company going; Dominique Mercy and Robert Sturm, and later Lutz Förster, stepped in as interim artistic directors. In 2017, outside expertise should have revived the company. Adolphe Binder, former artistic director of the Komische Oper Berlin’s dance theater and the Danskompanie Göteborg, was engaged but left after only one year due to differences with management. Continue reading “Resilient”

Legendary

“Swan Lake”
Bolshoi Ballet
Bolshoi Theatre
Moscow, Russia
September 7 and 8, 2026 (Historic Stage)

by Ilona Landgraf
Copyright © 2026 by Ilona Landgraf

1. Ensemble, “Swan Lake” by Y.Grigorovich, Bolshoi Ballet 2026 © Bolshoi Theatre/N.VoronovaThe Bolshoi Ballet is legendary for its Swan Lake. The first performance took place in 1877, almost one hundred and fifty years ago. This September, the swans danced for the 1,868th time, which translates to roughly thirteen Swan Lakes per year. Since 2001, the company has performed Yuri Grigorovich’s version, which includes scenes by Marius Petipa, Lev Ivanov, and Alexander Gorsky.

Grigorovich’s Swan Lake is grand. Its concepts and ideals represent the highest achievements of humanity and culture—dignity, decorum, grace, love, and unmatched beauty—and it shows how easily human nature can be led awry. Compared to Vladimir Bourmeister’s Swan Lake at the Stanislavsky Theatre, a ballet that reveals the protagonists’ inner life like none I’ve seen so far, Grigorovich portrays them as emblematic figures in an allegory, the sad ending of which Tchaikovsky’s prologue forebodes. Continue reading “Legendary”

Focused

“Anna Karenina”
Ballet of the Stanislavsky and Nemirovich-Danchenko Moscow Music Theatre
Stanislavsky and Nemirovich-Danchenko Moscow Music Theatre
Moscow, Russia
September 05, 2026 (evening performance)

by Ilona Landgraf
Copyright © 2026 by Ilona Landgraf

 1. E.Mikirticheva (Anna Karenina) and D.Dmitriev (Count Vronsky), “Anna Karenina” by M.Sevagin, Stanislavsky Ballet 2026 © MAMT/K.Zhitkova Over the past twenty years, Leo Tolstoy’s Anna Karenina has become increasingly popular among choreographers. In 2011, the Mariinsky Ballet toured Alexei Ratmansky’s 2004 adaptation to Baden-Baden. It told the story in retrospect, beginning with the heroine’s suicide, and it revolved primarily around her. I only remember Anna’s red dress, trains, and a lot of steam. Christian Spuck’s 2014 version for Zurich Ballet tried to retell the story in jam-packed, hectically changing scenes while wasting time on insignificant aspects. In John Neumeier’s 2017 ballet, Vronsky was a fancy lacrosse player, and the story was infused with sentimentality (I well remember its bare-chested Levin with a cowboy hat, sitting on a stack of straw next to an old farm tractor with his arms enthusiastically stretched toward a full moon and accompanied by Cat Stevens’s Moonshadow). Continue reading “Focused”

First Time

“Cinderella”
Bolshoi Ballet
Bolshoi Theatre
Moscow, Russia
September 05, 2026 (Historic Stage)

by Ilona Landgraf
Copyright © 2026 by Ilona Landgraf

1. E.Kokoreva (Cinderella), “Cinderella” by V.Lopatin, Bolshoi Ballet 2026 © Bolshoi Theatre/D.YusupovOf the two Cinderellas that premiered last May on major Russian stages in celebration of Sergei Prokofiev’s 135th birthday anniversary, I saw Nadezha Kalinina’s version for the Kazan Ballet a few weeks later on video. With some delay, I got to know Vyacheslav Lopatin’s Cinderella for the Bolshoi Ballet last Saturday during the new season’s opening matinee. Lopatin, principal of the company and fledgling ballet master, had never choreographed before. Giving his debut with no less than a full-blown production was due to the artistic director’s, Makhar Vaziev’s, encouragement and support. The outcome isn’t (and realistically couldn’t be) mind-boggling, but it is respectable.

Continue reading “First Time”

Torn Between Two

“Elláda” (“Minotaur”/“Leda and the Swans”)
MuzArts
Maly Theatre
Moscow, Russia
June 15 and 22, 2026 (video)

by Ilona Landgraf
Copyright © 2026 by Ilona Landgraf

1. D.Potaptsev (Minotaur) and ensemble, “Minotaur” by P.De Bana, MuzArts 2026 © MuzArts/A.StepanovIn mid-June, Moscow’s production company MuzArts premiered the double bill Elláda at the Maly Theatre. Moscow’s local press called MuzArts’ director, Yuri Baranov, “Russia’s current top ballet producer with an excellent grasp on the global ballet scene who knows how to create ideas, discover and recruit talent, and attract sponsors,”—in short, a Diaghilev 2.0. So I was glad that MuzArts’ executive producer, Daria Faezova, sent video recordings of both performances. If a company is in the vanguard of a dance scene as vibrant as Russia’s, you won’t want to miss their productions. Continue reading “Torn Between Two”

Squandered

“Scirocco” (“Death in Venice”/“Bridge of Sighs”)
WINNDance
Teatro Malibran
Venice, Italy
August 01, 2026

by Ilona Landgraf
Copyright © 2026 by Ilona Landgraf

 1. M.Rademaker, M.Galeazzi, D.Vishneva, S.Henriksen, and K.Everhart; “Death in Venice” by I. and M.van Opstal, O.R. De Jesús, and R.Behr; WINNDance 2026, photo courtesy of La Biennale di Venezia © A.Avezzù“When if not now” (WINN) is the attitude of movers and shakers. Earlier this year, two such movers and shakers, Slava Tutukin (former soloist of the Mikhailovsky Ballet, St. Petersburg, and the Aalto Ballet, Essen) and Marijn Rademaker (choreographer and ex-principal of Stuttgart Ballet and Dutch National Ballet) founded WINNDance, a Stuttgart-based dance company for dancers forty years old and older. It attracted renowned names: People’s Artist of Russia, Diana Vishneva; the late Hans van Manen’s muse, Igone de Jongh; Hamburg Ballet’s Ivan Urban, Silvia Azzoni, and Oleksandr Ryabko; the Royal Ballet’s former principal, Mara Galeazzi; and Polina Semionova (who didn’t perform in Venice). The new enterprise includes an educational platform (WINN&Learn) and an exploratory platform for collaboration with different industries (WINNLab). Continue reading “Squandered”

A Ballet Onion

“Ma Bayadère”
Les Ballets de Monte-Carlo
Forum Ludwigsburg
Ludwigsburg, Germany
July 24, 2026

by Ilona Landgraf
Copyright © 2026 by Ilona Landgraf

1. Ensemble, “Ma Bayadère” by J.-C.Maillot, Les Ballets de Monte-Carlo 2026 © H.GerritsenThe pronoun Ma in Les Ballets de Monte-Carlo’s 2025 Ma Bayadère is a clever modification. It allows the ballet’s creator, artistic director Jean-Christophe Maillot, to twist and mock Petipa’s La Bayadère with impunity while also advertising his brand. Ma Bayadère is like an onion of correlating layers. Like previous productions by Maillot, it reinterprets ballet history. Last weekend, the audience of the annual Ludwigsburg Festival had the opportunity to watch the German premiere of Ma Bayadère at the Ludwigsburg Forum.

Maillot transforms Petipa’s Indian Rajah from a palace ruler to a company’s choreographer who dances the role of the Rajah in his own La Bayadère. Niki, Gamza, and Solo are dancers of his company and prepare for the roles of the temple dancer, Nikiya, the Rajah’s daughter, Gamzatti, and the warrior, Solor, respectively. Continue reading “A Ballet Onion”

A Swansong and a Phoenix’s Rise from the Ashes

“Curtain Call”
Leonid Yacobson Ballet

Alexandrinsky Theatre
St. Petersburg, Russia
June 01, 2026 (video)

by Ilona Landgraf
Copyright © 2026 by Ilona Landgraf

1. V.Surkov and ensemble, “Curtain Call” by V.Samodurov, Leonid Yacobson Ballet 2026 © Leonid Yacobson Ballet/S.TyaginFew ballets have been so ingenious and gripping that I stopped taking notes so as not to miss a single moment. Vyacheslav Samodurov’s new choreography, Curtain Call, for the Leonid Yacobson Ballet, St. Petersburg, was one of them. Luckily, I received a video that I could replay.
The one-act piece premiered in early June as part of a triple bill alongside a new creation by Igor Bulytsyn’s (Bruch. Suite) and Samodurov’s 2024 award-winning 598 Beats. In mid-July, the company assembled all three pieces Samodurov has created for them so far (including the 2022 Cheeky Chastushki) in a new triple bill.

Continue reading “A Swansong and a Phoenix’s Rise from the Ashes”

Stellar

XV International Ballet Competition—Laureates’ Gala
Bolshoi Theatre
Moscow, Russia
July 05, 2026 (live stream)

by Ilona Landgraf
Copyright © 2026 by Ilona Landgraf

1. Laureates, XV International Ballet Competition 2026, Bolshoi Theatre © Press Center of the International Ballet CompetitionAfter three rounds of competition in ten days, the XV International Ballet Competition’s jury awarded medals, certificates, and diplomas to 50 of 131 contestants. Due to the high standards, discussions to determine the laureates continued late into the night after the final round. A laureates’ gala concert concluded the competition.

Of the seven gold medals, three were awarded to competitors from the USA and the Republic of Korea and one to a Japanese dancer. Russian dancers received seventeen prizes, Chinese six, and Mongolians four. Western Europe wasn’t represented, and only a few dancers from Central Europe scored: the Swede Auguste Marmus (bronze medal men, duet), coryphée and, as of late, Kammertänzer of the Hungarian National Ballet, the Serb Jana Zimonjic (bronze medal women, solo), and the Slovene Vid Vogrin (silver medal boys, duet). What mattered, though, wasn’t nationality but talent. Continue reading “Stellar”

“It is necessary to notice talent and to help it.”

XV International Ballet Competition
Bolshoi Theatre
Moscow, Russia

June 25–July 05, 2026 (live streams)

by Ilona Landgraf
Copyright © 2026 by Ilona Landgraf

1. Jung Yeonjoo (Republic of Korea), XV International Ballet Competition 2026, Bolshoi Theatre © Press Center of the International Ballet CompetitionLast week, the International Ballet Competition kicked off in Moscow for the fifteenth time since its foundation in 1969. This year, it is dedicated to Yuri Grigorovich (1927–2025), the competition’s artistic director and permanent chairman of the jury for more than half a century. His Legend of Love, performed by the Mariinsky Ballet, opened the competition.

Held every four years, the International Ballet Competition is compared to an Olympic contest in which participation is an honor. This year, a record 362 dancers from thirty-five countries applied, of whom 131 were invited to Moscow. They compete in two age categories—the junior group, ages 15-19 years, and the senior group, ages 20-27 years (many of whom are leading members of a company)—each divided into solo performances and duets. Laureates will emerge from Continue reading ““It is necessary to notice talent and to help it.””

Ambitious but Not Gripping

“Wonderland” (“Alice in Wonderland”/“Through the Looking-Glass”)
Hamburg Ballet 
Hamburg State Opera
Hamburg, Germany
June 20, 2026

by Ilona Landgraf
Copyright © 2026 by Ilona Landgraf

1. A.Martínez (The White Rabbit), “Wonderland” by A.Ratmansky, Hamburg Ballet 2026 © K.WestCompared to Alexei Ratmansky’s recent choreography, Callirhoe, for the Vienna State Ballet, his new creation, Wonderland, for the Hamburg Ballet feels empty. It combines two dance adaptations of Lewis Carroll’s most notable novels, Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland (1865) and its sequel Through the Looking-Glass (1871), each of which is presented in a one-hour act.

No doubt, the production is ambitious and elaborate. Ratmansky and his son, Vasyl, assembled different music for each of the no fewer than twenty-eight scenes, which Philip Feeney merged into a score. Erik Satie’s Three Gnossiennes, no.3, for example, lulls Alice (Olivia Betteridge) into her dream journey down the rabbit hole. Percy Grainger’s Molly on the Shore (amended by a cock-crow) gives the cackling animals at the Caucus race—among them a crab, mouse, dodo, and eaglet—a voice, Continue reading “Ambitious but Not Gripping”

Well on the Way

“Matinee Ballet Academy”
Ballet Academy of the Vienna State Opera
Vienna State Opera
Vienna, Austria
May 31, 2026

by Ilona Landgraf
Copyright © 2026 by Ilona Landgraf

1. Students of the Ballet Academy, “Presentation” by P.Armand et al., Ballet Academy of the Vienna State Opera 2026 © Vienna State Opera/A.Taylor Excitement permeated the Vienna State Opera as its auditorium filled for the Ballet Academy’s end-of-the-year performance last Sunday. One could feel the jitters of both the young artists and their families and friends who flocked to the performance. Their worries were unfounded; everything went as smoothly as could be wished.

Music by the Strauss family accompanied the opening Presentation, which assembled students of the 1.- 8. class. Its compilation of polkas, marches, gallops, and ball dances choreographed by the Academy’s director, Continue reading “Well on the Way”

Enlightening

“American Signatures”
Vienna State Ballet & Volksoper Wien
Volksoper Wien
Vienna, Austria
May 30, 2026

by Ilona Landgraf
Copyright © 2026 by Ilona Landgraf

1. J.Nakamura, “Interplay” by J.Robbins, Vienna State Ballet 2026 © Vienna State Ballet/A.Taylor2. G.Aime and G.Fredianelli, “Interplay” by J.Robbins, Vienna State Ballet 2026 © Vienna State Ballet/A.Taylor Of the four American choreographers included in the Vienna State Ballet’s mixed bill, American Signatures, only Jerome Robbins is well known in mainland Europe. Works by Pam Tanowitz, Lar Lubovitch, and Jessica Lang are rarely staged. Hence, I was glad to see this season’s last performance.

Robbin’s Interplay premiered in autumn 1945, shortly after World War II, as the second choreography in his oeuvre. Absolutely nothing in the piece hints at war. Instead, its eight dancers (four women and four men) portray unburdened, fun-loving youth with contagious optimism and self-assurance. A backdrop as gloriously blue as a summer sky intensifies the bright colors of the men’s shirts (with which they wear black, skintight pants and white socks) and the girls’ short dresses. Of course, they wear ponytails. The American way of living that they represent reminds me of Continue reading “Enlightening”